Skip to main content

User login

Loyola Professor becomes CoH's most hated player

35 replies [Last post]
marqaha
Sleepy --> Inattentive --> Caffeinated --> Beligerent --> Inattentive --> Sleepy
Vice President of Snark and Cynicism
marqaha's picture
Adversity Vice PresidentParticipated in 100 SG EventsMonster Mash
Joined: Dec 2 2007
Posts:
Check out this article.

Synopsis:
Quote:
Loyola Professor David Myers has been playing City of Heroes as part of his research. Which strikes me as a good thing to do. However, he’s been playing his Alt Twixt as… well, only obeying the rules of the game rather than the social rules. This lead to becoming one of the most hated players and recieving death-threats. He’s written a paper on it, and a book is forthcoming, but this article has an over-view of the events plus a link to one of his papers. Myers comes across somewhat naive, frankly. Gaming social groups act like social groups? Yeah, so what? And why shouldn’t they. Myers, from their perspective, was acting like a sociopath with no interest in societal mores.
__________________

Stop American Censorship!

toon
Baku's Furry Crotch Buddy
Justice Incarnate
toon's picture
Adversity MemberParticipated in 25 SG Events
Joined: Apr 27 2008
Posts:
I find it difficult to believe it was as completely one-sided as it seems in the article, but it is PVP we are talking about.
nethershock
Keeper of Peace
Adversity Member
Joined: Mar 25 2008
Posts:
lol CoX pvp
__________________

MstrRich
Hero of the City
MstrRich's picture
Adversity Member
Joined: Jun 29 2008
Posts:
Wait....CoX has PvP?
__________________

Moxy
Hero of the City
Moxy's picture
Adversity MemberParticipated in 25 SG EventsMonster Mash
Joined: Sep 23 2007
Posts:
I read the article and it's a bunch of crap. He purposely griefs people and then writes a paper about how they got mad. I love the parts where he describes how good he was. The whole thing is a joke and that guy's feeble claim to fame of tormenting pre-teens.
Omni
God Damn I am handsome
Vanguard Protectorate
Omni's picture
Adversity MemberParticipated in 100 SG Events
Joined: Dec 1 2007
Posts:
Omni's take:

read article. dumb. publicity whore writer. F him and his family and his mom and his cats and perhaps his pet chimp bubbles...

moving on, there is now a Tim Hortons in NYC and i had my first canadian maple this morning... NOT AS GOOD AS in Canada. your safe Canada... FOR NOW!!
__________________

MiseriChik
City of Heroes Community Leader
Goddess of Adversity
MiseriChik's picture
Adversity Vice PresidentParticipated in 100 SG EventsDark Heart of Animosity
Joined: Mar 1 2008
Posts:
"Wahhh Wahhh, no one likes me!"

"I griefed players and they calle me names...wahh wahh"


Craptacular.
__________________

STOP INTERNET CENSORSHIP

Orange Dragon
Legendary Hero
Orange Dragon's picture
Adversity Member
Joined: Sep 27 2007
Posts:
I think I'm going to write a book about University Professors and how they lack common sense and when they behave like douches people tend not to like them. I expect it to be a best seller.
marqaha
Sleepy --> Inattentive --> Caffeinated --> Beligerent --> Inattentive --> Sleepy
Vice President of Snark and Cynicism
marqaha's picture
Adversity Vice PresidentParticipated in 100 SG EventsMonster Mash
Joined: Dec 2 2007
Posts:
Well, clearly no one is disputing the "most hated player" claim. smile
__________________

Stop American Censorship!

Orion Pax
Lord of the Helmet
Midnight Guardian
Orion Pax's picture
Adversity CEOParticipated in 100 SG EventsHeart of AdversityMonster MashOriginal SG Tailor
Joined: Sep 23 2007
Posts:
I think I'll pre-order Dragon's upcoming best seller on Amazon wink Seriously though, this guy's a douche and a serious asshat meh
__________________


Blastagedon
Minecraft Conductor
Hero of the City
Blastagedon's picture
Adversity Member
Joined: May 26 2009
Posts:
you could have stopped reading here:

"David Myers, a Loyola professor and computer game scholar"

WTF is a computer game scholar? I believe he has the office right next to Peter Venkman.

I for one have never heard of the most hated player in the COH universe, apparently if you are a computer game scholar you can make up titles like that for your self.

From now on please refer to me as the most equivocal player in the COH unverse. I may also dub myself COH professor emeritus.
__________________

Rehab is for Quitters!

Peregrin
Back in CoH and Back in Debt
Midnight Guardian
Peregrin's picture
Adversity Member
Joined: Sep 24 2007
Posts:
And I'm now officially the player who is the most like Peregrin.....
__________________

Vires per Varietas

Shaaktar
Married with children.... Trying to play.......LOL
Freedom Phalanx Member
Shaaktar's picture
Adversity Member
Joined: Oct 10 2007
Posts:
And you guys can Call me as "Master" and i demand some PL













LOL

Just a joke guys, but you felt offend i blame Pax
__________________

-------------------------------------------
http://www.facebook.com/luizguilherme.figueiredo
Very restricted play time, but willing to join any team

Northern Lady
Vice President of Smoked Salmon and Niceness
Northern Lady's picture
Adversity MemberParticipated in 50 SG Events
Joined: Jun 19 2009
Posts:
My brother read this story and told me all about it (seriously, he went on for quite some time, lol)....sounds like a realy meany frown
marqaha
Sleepy --> Inattentive --> Caffeinated --> Beligerent --> Inattentive --> Sleepy
Vice President of Snark and Cynicism
marqaha's picture
Adversity Vice PresidentParticipated in 100 SG EventsMonster Mash
Joined: Dec 2 2007
Posts:
Wow, I didn't get any of the same impressions most of you got. Maybe its because I agree with the inference that all PVPers act like unsupervised 12 year-olds and regard pvp-n00bs are interlopers in their sacred playground. meh


See? I can get away with that kind of hyperbole because I now know that I'm not the most hated CoH player.
__________________

Stop American Censorship!

Moxy
Hero of the City
Moxy's picture
Adversity MemberParticipated in 25 SG EventsMonster Mash
Joined: Sep 23 2007
Posts:
On the contrary:

He was acting in a way to deliberately grief other players. CoH had made many pleas for players to stop that exact behaviour. What he did basically was to ruin other people's fun. I'm pretty sure that I would get quite a bit of hate if I deliberately sabotaged SFs and TFs (which can be easily accomplished). Sorry Marq, I believe the guy is an pompous ass regardless of PvP or PvE community.
Razorstrike
Arrogant Hero
Razorstrike's picture
Adversity Vice PresidentSG Tailor 2008VG Tailor 2007
Joined: Sep 24 2007
Posts:
Well the thing about this guy, is that despite the fact that he was using what GM's and devs have deemed as acceptable PvP practices, he wasn't doing anything that requires skill and only encourages bad behavior and negative reactions. I mean all he did was run around zones and fear villains and then TP them into hostile NPC mobs where the villain would die almost instantly. So yeah, most people would consider that griefing and would elicit negative comments/reactions.


Though as for the rest of what he did, isn't it kinda messed up with how he did his "experiments"? I mean shouldn't he have been observing and had other people actually doing the work? Cause this provides a bit of irony to have his real life name/location revealed when he was getting death threats...
__________________



You don't want to end up like the brave, fallen, and genetically-altered personnel we've come across.
-Officer Orb

War Griffon
"Last to get to 50"
Legendary Hero
War Griffon's picture
Adversity MemberParticipated in 50 SG Events
Joined: Jun 29 2009
Posts:
Well - I can't comment on this guys use of PvP(mostly because I've never been). It seems he had a predetermined goal to "experiment" by griefing players to prove his theory "players are social misfits". Like many overeducated acedemics, he just wanted to prove his pet theory, not provide an unbiased look into gaming. I heard today on the radio, that on-line gaming is growing faster than any other liesure activity. Not sure if this is true, but evidenced by my recent joining, at least, some might conclude this to be true(perhaps I'm a "social misfit", which O.K. by me).

I'm sure he is happy to be published. Perhaps he go away and never grace us with his awesome presence in-game.

Wow that sounded almost coherent - someone blast me with a energy ray or something, quick before I start to take myself seriuosly!! overkill

P.S. I blame Pax!!
__________________

Commentary Catalyst (Goader)

marqaha
Sleepy --> Inattentive --> Caffeinated --> Beligerent --> Inattentive --> Sleepy
Vice President of Snark and Cynicism
marqaha's picture
Adversity Vice PresidentParticipated in 100 SG EventsMonster Mash
Joined: Dec 2 2007
Posts:
War Griffon wrote:
Wow that sounded almost coherent - someone blast me with a energy ray or something, quick before I start to take myself seriuosly!! :overkill:


Don't worry, as a general rule the more coherent you are the less we take you seriously. smile

I guess I'm not seeing what must be painfully obvious. He wasn't doing anything against the rules. If he was just a jerk this seems like a disproportionate response. What a fascinating discussion this has become. I need to go back and re-read the article to understand the perspective the rest of you more or less share.

Y'know what I appreciate? The whole SG has united against some selfish jerk and is quick to squash his rude behavior... and for once the jerk isn't me! happy dance
__________________

Stop American Censorship!

Peregrin
Back in CoH and Back in Debt
Midnight Guardian
Peregrin's picture
Adversity Member
Joined: Sep 24 2007
Posts:
I want him to try another experiment.

Lets see how many social misfits take the bus in any major city.
Lets have him ride the bus everyday for a month. He'll then proceed to elbow people, stand/sit too close to them, talk really loudly to people, cut in line, step on toes, and take people's seats... all technically legal activities.

I want to know how long he'll survive.

What poor scientific method.
__________________

Vires per Varietas

Razorstrike
Arrogant Hero
Razorstrike's picture
Adversity Vice PresidentSG Tailor 2008VG Tailor 2007
Joined: Sep 24 2007
Posts:
The guy used tactics that have been debated and discussed by players, and often become flame wars, on the official forums. Things like TPing into NPC's or droning are despised by probably 95% of the player base, and when you have some player that uses this tactic they end up becoming notorious and despised.

Pinnacle had something similar to this, there was a player who would target villains and TP them into groups of Longbow and then pin them via force bubbles or other repel powers. There were threads calling this player out, rallying other players to beat the snot out of him, ect. Heroes in the PvP zones would help the villains to chase off this player. It was one of those rare times when players who hated each other would team up and help out each other.

So yeah, while these people were doing things considered legit by the devs...the players have developed their own set of rules and code of conduct that pretty much anyone followed and these guys went in the face of that. People went into these zones to have challenges against other players and have some sense of enjoyment out of it - and these sort of deviant tactics were the opposite. Players got pissed off because it was no fun to be killed repeatedly by NPC's and earn debt and also have no chance to do anything in the zones. And if you can't chase the person off, you get even more angry and either you end up leaving the zone or you vent somewhere about it all.
__________________



You don't want to end up like the brave, fallen, and genetically-altered personnel we've come across.
-Officer Orb

Peregrin
Back in CoH and Back in Debt
Midnight Guardian
Peregrin's picture
Adversity Member
Joined: Sep 24 2007
Posts:
So in essence, what he's calling social misfits is in fact the community banding together to create its own social rules and ensuring consequences to those who flagrantly break those rules.

Again, he's got some pretty flawed method. I wonder what kind of a research grant he got for this?
Maybe I should have studied to be a professor of gameology.
__________________

Vires per Varietas

MiseriChik
City of Heroes Community Leader
Goddess of Adversity
MiseriChik's picture
Adversity Vice PresidentParticipated in 100 SG EventsDark Heart of Animosity
Joined: Mar 1 2008
Posts:
Yeah, where do I sign up for that job?!

It would beat mine for sure!

meh
__________________

STOP INTERNET CENSORSHIP

marqaha
Sleepy --> Inattentive --> Caffeinated --> Beligerent --> Inattentive --> Sleepy
Vice President of Snark and Cynicism
marqaha's picture
Adversity Vice PresidentParticipated in 100 SG EventsMonster Mash
Joined: Dec 2 2007
Posts:
Peregrin wrote:
So in essence, what he's calling social misfits is in fact the community banding together to create its own social rules and ensuring consequences to those who flagrantly break those rules.


I feel compelled to point this out. Part of the result of his study was to discover that people will degenerate into real mobs, despite the virtual environment. If this was his goal then I cna't help but observe that he found the results he expected. Of course he also contaminated the study and his scientific method is clearly suspect.
__________________

Stop American Censorship!

War Griffon
"Last to get to 50"
Legendary Hero
War Griffon's picture
Adversity MemberParticipated in 50 SG Events
Joined: Jun 29 2009
Posts:
You guys are already Prof's of gameology, Just no cool grant money or published papers(excepting this fantabulous forum) to prop your views. Perhaps you do not need to be propped. Perhaps your ego is strong enough to not require such props. or....

Maybe we are all in the same social "misfit" category, and can not see his point of view. or....

I don't care what the putz writes about, as long as I'm having fun pounding "evil" its good enough for my myopic point of view. read

Apparently he needs these things, like we need to play. shrug
__________________

Commentary Catalyst (Goader)

Peregrin
Back in CoH and Back in Debt
Midnight Guardian
Peregrin's picture
Adversity Member
Joined: Sep 24 2007
Posts:
rofl i agree
__________________

Vires per Varietas

Blastagedon
Minecraft Conductor
Hero of the City
Blastagedon's picture
Adversity Member
Joined: May 26 2009
Posts:
Perhaps even more interesting than the article are the comments posted below it. The comments range from "All online gamers are fat, lazy, unemployed couch potatoes" to 'All gamers are the next round of bazillionaires in the making".

I think this guy is a complete toolbag just based on the way that the article is so one sided and self aggrandizing (sp?). I understand that he was supposedly conducting an experiment, but I think his findings are about as revolutionary as declaring that water is wet.
__________________

Rehab is for Quitters!

Peregrin
Back in CoH and Back in Debt
Midnight Guardian
Peregrin's picture
Adversity Member
Joined: Sep 24 2007
Posts:
Blastagedon wrote:
... I think his findings are about as revolutionary as declaring that water is wet.


I'm constantly amazed at the number of grants that get given out for studies that determine things like:

People who are rude don't get served as well in retail outlets
or
Using less safety gear while rock climbing increases the risk of injury
or my favourite:
Eating fast food exclusively, and agreeing to upsize even if you're not hungery, will have detrimental effects on your health.
__________________

Vires per Varietas

War Griffon
"Last to get to 50"
Legendary Hero
War Griffon's picture
Adversity MemberParticipated in 50 SG Events
Joined: Jun 29 2009
Posts:
How about we try for a grant to determine if for extended periods of time affects your social abilities(for instance if you play all x2 exp weekend long will you loose sleep, get grumpy, be short with family, affect work performance on Monday, etc.). My theory is that adverse effects are not recognizable(sp) for at least 48 hours.

You can live on Monster and sugar for extended periods, can't you? pray
__________________

Commentary Catalyst (Goader)

Peregrin
Back in CoH and Back in Debt
Midnight Guardian
Peregrin's picture
Adversity Member
Joined: Sep 24 2007
Posts:
War Griffon wrote:
...
You can live on Monster and sugar for extended periods, can't you? :pray:


I'll settle for some really good espresso.
__________________

Vires per Varietas

FX
Big Yellow Head
Participated in 50 SG Events
Joined: Sep 27 2007
Posts:
Peregrin wrote:


I'll settle for some really good espresso.



i agree THIS!